uSwitch.com Mobile Phone News

Nokia N8: dead on arrival?

Comment

Posted at 11:26am by

Just what is Nokia up to? Four months after the N8 was proudly touted in all its glory, it appears its release date has slipped once again, with UK retailer Play.com pushing the new flagship phone back to October 8th. That’s nearly two months after it was supposed to hit shelves.

But this isn’t a simple delay. There are wider machinations at play here. MeeGo is due to land in the same month, the new OS set to take over from Symbian on Nokia’s high-end handsets and therefore rendering the N8 utterly redundant just as it gets ready to roll. But it’s the leak of the N8-replacing N9 that’s really got alarm bells ringing.

nokia n9

The new device is said to be coming in the first week of December. If that doesn’t undermine the N8 and the excessive hype Nokia has attempted to create around it, then what does? On paper, the N8 is a stunner. Awesome 12 megapixel camera with Carl Zeiss optics, feature-laden and new-look OS, an app store with great potential in the form of Ovi and a capacitive touchscreen tell you that much.

Initial previews have been cautiously optimistic, but the fact is the N9 can’t kick it alongside the Samsung Galaxy S, iPhone 4 or HTC Desire if it’s not been released. Specs on paper can only do so much and it’s a worry that more delays are afoot. Just what is up with the phone for it to be held back for so long? Delays like this don’t inspire confidence in the all-important first adopters who will be buying the phone from the get go. However, the mooted N9 is of the biggest concern. It, too, looks amazing. But why release it so soon after the N8?

It would seem Nokia has no confidence in Symbian 3, otherwise why would it be releasing a successor just two months on from its arrival. Mobile phone makers are always upgrading, but the days of trailing handsets for months on end are over.

The HTC Desire was out in the wild within weeks of its announcement at MWC 2010 in February. The Samsung Galaxy S landed quick smart once it got the official nod. Nokia’s N8 should have been out months ago. Trying to repeat the trick Apple pulled off with the original iPhone hasn’t worked. That teaser period was for a gadget that redefined the mobile phone space. The N8 might be good, but it’s not revolutionary.

Nokia N8

The confusion here, though, points to a wider malaise at Nokia. The unresolved issue of whether Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo is staying or going as CEO and the failure to land a punch on Apple or Google while the latter pair surge up the smartphone charts show this is a company far from its best.

Fans and supporters will point to its position as smartphone top dog. But that is quickly being challenged and this is more of a cultural problem. Nokia lacks that psychological edge. Not since the N95 has it really caused a stir, instead delivering disappointing flagship phones that don’t excite those after the latest bleeding-edge technology.

The N9 may well be the Android and iPhone beater that Nokia has been waiting for. But if it lands this side of Christmas, the N8 won’t stand a chance. Espoo’s strategy is almost impossible to understand. And while it flails, Google will unleash Android 3.0 and Apple will be beavering away on yet another iPhone. The time to have a complete rethink is now.

Check out the Nokia N8 in action below

More news on: Nokia, Upcoming mobile phones, Symbian mobile phones, Nokia N8, NSeries mobile phones

7 Comments

  • REVENANT, 20th August 2010.

    Why write it off before it's even out? Everyone is hating on Nokia now. It's like it;s the hippest thing.

    All it would take is one killer phone and they'd be right back up there.

    Reply
  • @top10, 20th August 2010, via Twitter.

    Nokia N8: is the Finns' latest NSeries smartphone dead on arrival? Here's Joe Minihane's take: http://bit.ly/dfyBfm #nokia #n8 #technology

  • Matthias, 20th August 2010.

    I've got the idea we're in for a few surprises with nokia the upcoming months...

    Reply
  • Josh, 20th August 2010.

    I have been keeping an eye on a Nokia killer smartphone (i.e kills the competition, not killer features on paper). The Nokia N8 is not it. Nokia needs to do much more to regain the good faith lost with the N97.

    Also, Nokia's company direction is not clear at all. Is Symbian^3 just a one-off fling? Can devices with S^3 be upgraded to S^4? What will happen to the N8 as it is the last of the N series to be loaded with Symbian before the switch to Meego (how about N900's Maemo?)

    And what's with the huge delay for the N8?

    The problem with Nokia is that it is using a strategy for making dumbphones (the industry in which it dominates well) to make smartphones. It will not work. Investors have already expressed concern. The fate of OPK to stay on as Nokia CEO is still unknown. Uncertainty will destroy you in such a competitive industry.

    Reply
  • Toucan Murphy, 21st August 2010.

    What they are doing is QA. Something you may find missing, for example, in rushed to market, iPhone Flaw.

    N8 is only mid range and will be priced so despite the high features but s3.

    N9 will be high features same price range nice os meego.

    Reply
  • Mark, 22nd August 2010.

    You're missing the point, Joe. The general public doesn't give a damn about the operating system as long as it's simple to use, intuitive and gets the job done which Symbian^3 appears to be.

    The people who buy the N8 will buy it because it's an excellent camera phone, media player and has apps too. That's what matters. The people who buy an N9 will have other needs.

    Nokia release many phones to many market segments with varying needs. Therefore they're always going to release multiple products. I don't see why tech journalists find this so hard to comprehend.

    Reply
  • @Mark, 6th November 2010.

    Quote: "The general public doesn't give a damn about the operating system as long as it's simple to use, intuitive and gets the job done which Symbian^3 appears to be."

    Lemme correct it for you: "For smartphones, the general public does give a damn about the operating system as long as it's simple to use, intuitive and gets the job done, which Symbian^3 has been proven to be not."

    Since the N8 has already been released, I think my current assessment carries more weight than the desperate optimism on the part of Nokia/Symbian fans several months ago. ("The phone isn't released yet! The firmware isn't finalized yet!")

    Reply

Add your comment